Monday, 12 October 2020

A Different History - Poem Analysis


Analysis of the Poem

Great Pan - Greek God of Nature. This God is shown as having the head of the Goat and body of a man. This shows the division in one’s self. The poet is like this - There are two identities in her. One is Indian and the other one is US citizen. Two cultures.

 

Pan is also the God of music. The word emigration refers to the way the culture travelled from Greece to India. Alexander the Great brought the Greek culture to India when he fought the battle of Hydaspes (326 BC) where he defeated the King Porus. 

 

The reference to the exotic animals - snakes and monkeys show how they are part of the Indian culture. Hanuman or Anjaneya and worshipping the snake. 

 

Literature and books came from Nature. 

 

The personification of book and tree - rude to a book and offending the tree

 

Saraswathi - Goddess of Music and literature. 

Memories of how we respected the book. 

 

The second stanza has ‘Which language’ repeated twice - rhetorical question - answer is English

The poem becomes a political one with the use of some violent images. 

The second stanza also talks about erasing cultures

 

Many violent images in the second stanza: 

Murder

Torture

Cropped - Soul has been cropped - reshaped, reduce and resized

Oppressor’s tongue 

Conqueror’s face

Swooped 

Scythe - Pronounced as sayeth 

The Unborn children they still love that strange language 

 

One of the main themes of the poem is Language and Identity 

The angry tone in the second stanza

The lines are free and open structure 

Emphasis is on the message rather than the rhyme

 

English Rule and how it affected India’s growth 

The way culture evolved 

Language is identity 

Language is thought 

 

Many languages are dying 

Extended Activity - Listen to the poem and practice the pronunciation 

Try to imitate the style of the poet’s language 

Trace the influence of the American accent in her language 

No comments: